# Finding a needle in a haystack–how to deal with noise in the data?

Scientists have used indirect measurements of movement to infer the presence of waves for a very long time.  For example, how can you tell when it’s windy without going outside?  You look to see the movements of the trees or flags or other flexible structures.

Now, scientists at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory are using lasers to measure gravitational waves.  Gravitational waves were predicted by Albert Einstein, but only in the last few years has the equipment gotten sensitive enough to attempt measurements.  The scientists face the task of detecting a wave that’s 0.000000000005 meters tall from spacecraft 5,000,000,000 meters away!
Using known masses attached to spacecrafts and lasers that measure the positions of the masses, the scientists hope to detect the movements caused by gravitational waves.  Lasers, although very precise, are still too noisy to measure the gravitational waves.  (Learn more about noise and using indirect measurements in our “Is there life outside of Earth?” investigation.)
What’s the solution to the noise problem, finding that tiny little wave across trillions of miles?  Generate artificial noise in the lab and see if you can still detect the signal.  It’s worked in the laboratory, so scientists may soon be able to detect gravitational waves in space.
The ability to detect smaller and smaller motions will enhance the ability of instruments to detect smaller and smaller planets around other stars–perhaps even another “Earth.”  Technological innovation is the only limit.

## 2 thoughts on “Finding a needle in a haystack–how to deal with noise in the data?”

1. Jen

What great information for my 8th graders! My students are so curious to know how scientists have determined how we truly know there are stars and other planets in our universe. This helps them understand indirect measurements and observations. The information is easy to read (which helps with scientific comprehension) and is a nice compliment to what I am teaching in class. A great resource.

2. Jon

So many students think in absolutes and have trouble with “noise” in science. When looking at graphs and asked to describe the overall trend, most tell me it wiggles up and down, and up and down. They are describing the “noise” in the data and are not seeing the overall trend. Articles like this are a quick read and will help them learn more about “noise” in data.