The most fascinating part of science is the search of answers to strange phenomena. In the past nine months, I have posted more than fifty IR videos on my Infrared YouTube channel
. These experiments are all very easy to do, but not all of them are easy to explain. In this blog post, I will try to explain one of those experiments
, with one of my other skills -- molecular simulation.
This simple IR experiment concerns with putting a piece of paper above a cup of room temperature (nearly) water (Figure 1). I hear you saying, what is the big deal of it? You have probably done that several times in your life, for whatever reasons.
If you happen to have an IR camera and you look at this process through it, you may be surprised. Many of you know that water in an open cup is slightly cooler ( 1-2°C lower) than room temperature because of evaporative cooling: constant evaporation of water molecules from liquid water brings away thermal energy from the cup and causes it to remain a bit cooler than the room environment (which is why you feel cold when you step out of a swimming pool). You may think that the paper would also cool down because at room temperature paper is a bit warmer than the water in the cup and, based on what your science teacher has told you, heat would flow from the warmer paper to the cooler water, causing the paper to cool down.
But the result is exactly opposite -- the paper actually warms up (Figure 2)! And the warming appears to be pretty significant -- up to 2°C can be observed in a dry winter day. I don't know your reaction to this finding, but I was baffled when I saw it because I was expecting to see cooling and this effect appeared to be a violation of the Second Law of Thermodynamics
(which, of course, is impossible)! In fact, the reason I did this experiment was to figure out how sensitive my IR camera could be. My intention was to exploit the small temperature difference resulting from evaporative cooling of water as a stable lower-temperature source. I was examining if the IR camera could catch the miniscule heat transfer between the water and the paper.
I quickly figured out that the culprit responsible for this strange heating phenomenon must come from the water vapor, which we cannot see with the naked eye. But what we can't see doesn't mean it doesn't exist. When water molecules in the vapor encounters the surface molecules of the paper, they will be captured. When more and more water molecules are captured and condense onto the paper surface, they will return to the liquid state and, according to the Law of Conservation of Energy
, release the excessive energy they carry, which causes the paper to warm up. In other words, the paper somehow recovers the energy lost in the cup through evaporation. As you can see now, this is a pretty delicate thermodynamic cycle
that connects two phase changes, evaporation and condensation, in two different places and their latent heats. The physicists among us would appreciate if I say that this shows entropy at work: evaporation is an entropic effect
that is caused by water molecules wanting to maximize their entropy by leaving their more organized liquid state. The interaction between the vapor and the paper acts to reverse this process by returning the water molecules to the condensed liquid state and a certain amount of net energy can be extracted from this (known as the enthalpy of vaporization
|Figure 4: Sensor results.|
At this point, I hope you have been enticed enough to want to try this out yourself. If you don't have an IR camera, you can use a temperature sensor or an IR thermometer as a substitution to observe this phenomenon (of course, nothing beats an IR camera in terms of seeing heat -- with a point thermometer you just need to be patient and be willing to do more tedious work).
But wait, this is not the end of the story!
If you keep observing the paper, you will see that this condensation heating effect will diminish in a few minutes (Figure 3). This trend is more clearly shown in Figure 4 in which the temperature of the paper was recorded for ten minutes using a fast-response surface temperature sensor
. What happens?
The answer to this question can be illustrated using a schematic molecular simulation
(Figure 5) I designed to explain the underlying molecular physics (in that simulation water molecules are simplified as single round particles). After water molecules condense onto the paper surface, a thin layer of condensate will form. When it becomes thick enough, water molecules will evaporate from it, too, just like from the surface layer of water in the cup. When the rate of evaporation equals the rate of condensation, there is no more net heating: The condensation heating and evaporative cooling will reach the "break-even" point. Reaching this equilibrium state doesn't mean that condensation and evaporation on the surface of the paper will stop. In fact, water molecules will keep condensing to the layer and evaporating from it. This is known as "dynamic equilibrium
." If you move the paper, you will break this dynamic equilibrium. Figure 6 shows a pattern in which evaporative cooling and condensation heating occurred simultaneously on a single piece of paper after the paper had been shifted a bit. In Figure 6, evaporation dominated in the blue zone that was shifted out of the cup area, condensation dominated in the white zone that was shifted into the cup area, and the overlap zone in the middle remained close to the equilibrium state because it was the zone that still remained inside the cup area -- so business as usual.
As you can see, there is a lot of science in this "simple" experiment! Nothing we have done so far requires expensive materials or supplies. Everything needed to do this experiment is probably within the reach of your arm if you are reading this article at home (and you happen to have a digital thermometer, or better, an IR camera, nearby). If you are a science teacher, this experiment should fascinate you because you know this will be a perfect inquiry activity for your students. If you are a building professional, this experiment should fascinate you because you know how important hygrothermal dynamics is in driving moisture transport in the building envelope. If you are a scientist, this experiment should fascinate you because what I have shown you is in fact an atomic layer deposition
experiment that anyone can do -- some Fermi calculation
suggests that the thickness of the layer is in the nanometer range (only a few hundred layers of water molecules or 1/10,000th of the diameter of your hair). What we are seeing is in fact a signal from the nanoscale world! Isn't that cool?
Does our story end now? Absolutely no. The new questions you can ask will be practically endless if you keep "thinking molecularly." The following are six extended questions I have asked myself. You can try all of these without leaving your kitchen.When will the paper cool down?
Returning to the original purpose of my experiment (looking for cooling due to heat transfer), can we find a situation in which we will indeed see cooling instead of heating? Yes, if the water is cold enough (Figure 7). When the water is cold, the evaporation rate drops. There will be less water molecules hitting the surface of the paper. The energy gain from weaker condensation heating cannot compensate the energy loss due to the heat transfer between the paper and the cold water. (By the way, I think the heat transfer in this case is mostly radiative, because air doesn't conduct heat well and natural convection acts against heat transfer in this situation.)What if the paper has been atop the water for a long time?
If you leave the paper atop the cup of water for a few hours and you come back to examine it, you would probably be surprised again: The paper is now cooler than room temperature (Figure 8). I wouldn't be surprised if you are totally confused now: This heating and cooling business is indeed quite elusive -- even though everything we have done so far has been limited to manipulating paper and water. To keep the story short, I will tell you that this is because water molecules have traveled through the porous layer of the paper through capillary action
and shown up on the other side of the paper (this molecular movement is often known as percolation
in physics). Their evaporation from the upper side of the paper cools down the paper. The building science guys among us can use this experiment to teach moisture transport through materials. Can the temperature of the upper side be somehow used to gauge the moisture vapor transmission rate
(MVTR) of a porous material? If so, this may provide a way to automatically measure MVTR of different materials. The American Society for Testing and Materials already has established a standard
based on IR sensors. Perhaps this experiment can be related to that. Different materials have different dew points?
Do water molecules condense to other materials such as plastic? We know plastic materials do not absorb water (which is why they are good vapor barriers). If plastic materials are not cold enough, water molecules do not condense to them.
Figure 9 shows this difference by using a piece of paper half-covered by a transparency film taped to the underside. Heating was only observed in the paper part, indicating water molecules do not condense to the plastic film. This experiment raises an interesting question: The so-called dew point
, the temperature below which the water vapor in the air at a constant barometric pressure will condense into liquid water, may not be an entirely reliable way to predict condensation. Condensation actually depends on the chemical property of the material surface. Hydrophobic (water-hating) materials like plastic tend to have a low dew point, whereas hydrophilic (water-loving) materials tend to have a high dew point. The porosity
of the material should matter, too, because a more porous material will provide a large surface for interaction with water molecule -- paper happens to be such a material because of its fiber texture. If you are a building professional and you worry about moisture, you probably should have this in your mind. Vapor pressure depression
What will happen if we add some salt (or baking soda or sugar) to the water? Figure 10 shows that the condensation heating effect becomes weaker. For our chemist friends, this is known as vapor pressure depression
. The salt ions do not evaporate themselves, but their presence in a solution slows down the evaporation of water molecules.A vapor column
What will happen if the paper approaches the water from a different angle like in the vertical direction? How does the shape of the water vapor distribution above a cup of water look like? Does it look like a steam from a cup of coffee? Figure 11 could probably give you some clue.What about alcohol?
So far we have used only water. What about other liquids? Alcohol is pretty volatile. So I tried some isopropyl alcohol
(91%). Once again, I was baffled. Our experience with applying rubbing alcohol to our skin says that alcohol cools faster than water. So I expected that when the isopropanol molecules condense, they would release more heat. But this is not what Figure 12 suggests! Given the fact that the enthalpies of vaporization of alcohol and water are 44 and 41 kJ/mol, respectively, the only sensible explanation may be that the heating effect is not only due to the condensation of the vapor molecules, but also the interaction between the vapor molecules and the surface molecules of the paper. If the interaction between an alcohol molecule and a paper molecule is weaker, then the adsorption of the alcohol molecule onto the paper surface will produce less heat. I don't know how to prove this now, but this could be a good topic to research.Final words
Even if this is a lengthy blog post (and thanks for making it to the end), I am pretty sure that the scientific exploration does not stop here. There are other questions that you can ask yourself. For me, I have been intrigued by the fascinating thermodynamic cycle and have been wondering if that could be used to engineer something that can harvest that latent heat. In other words, could we turn a cup of water into a tiny power plant to charge my cell phone? The evaporation of water molecules from an open cup is a free gift of entropy from Nature. Perhaps something could be done about it.